Ijarah has huge potential as a financing mode for Islamic
banks. It can be used for meeting the needs of retail, corporate and the public
sectors and can also play a crucial role in promoting Islamic finance industry.
Leasing is an attractive mode of investment for Islamic banks for the following
a) Assets acquired under these contracts are
usually of high quality, marketable, maintain their market value well above
book value, are movable and are easily disposable for cash in case of default.
b) Because of the good quality of the asset, the
bank, as lessor, does not have to depend so much on the creditworthiness of the
lessee, since it always has the recourse of selling the asset in case of
c) It is possible for the banks to get variable and
floating return on long term investments.
Ijarah can be used directly for plants a machinery, autos,
housing and consumer durables and indirectly for sukuk issues by the
corporate and the government sectors. It can be used to develop different
contracts and sukuk that may suit different purposes of issuers and the sukuk
holders. Public and private sector corporations can use the securitisation
on the basis of ijarah as alternative tool to interest based borrowing
provided they have durable and useable assets. Ijarah is conducive to the
formation of fixed assets and medium and long-term investments in an economy. Ijarah
Sukuk will be discussed in detail in the Module on Treasury and Capital
Market Operations dealing with Islamic Financial Markets.
Leasing and investment
As an asset-based lending is a permitted form of
debt-financing in Islam, ijarah provides an alternative to
interest-based investment in assets for the Islamic banks. The goods in
which the investment is to be made are not purchased by the actual user,
but by the bank or a finance company, and are made available to the contracting
partner for commercial use subject to payment of a lease rental which is the
investment return. This form of financing offers Islamic banks various
benefits, such as:
• Secured investment, thus reducing credit risks.
Because of the good quality of the asset, the bank does not have to depend so
much on the creditworthiness of the lessee client, since it always has the
recourse of selling the asset in case of default.
• Assets acquired are usually of high quality,
marketable, maintain their market value well above the book value, are moveable
and are easily disposable for cash in case of default.
• Although it is a longer-term financing instrument,
a leasing contract can be reviewed periodically. The financing party thus not
tied down to a fixed return that may not be in its investment goals. The rent
can be tied to any type of index agreed to.
• Clear basis of calculation returns over the term of
the lease period
• Scope for new investments
• Tax benefits for both parties
Islamic banks are able to offer leasing
certificates to their depositor clients as specific investment certificates as
a form of declining equity. Lease payments include two elements: capital
repayments and profit. If both of these are refunded to the certificate holder,
net of bank costs, the depositor client recoups part of the capital (the
client’s deposit) as the lease gets closer to the end of its term. But it is
possible to design certificates which pay the holder dividends only; so that
the bank can reinvest the incoming capital repayments in other lease contracts.
Ijarah Muntahia-bi-tamleek (Ijarah
Ijarah Munahia-bi-tamleek (Ijarah-wa-iktana) is
variation of the leasing method and similar to ijarah except that,
included in the contract, is a promise from the lessee to buy the leased asset
at a pre-agreed price; rentals paid during the lease term constitute part of
the purchase price and the final sale being for a token sum. Ijarah
shares many common features with lease financing and operating lease /
hirepurchase arrangements. It involves a lessor (usually a financial
institution) purchasing an asset and renting it to a lessee for a specific time
period at an agreed rental and at the end of the lease period transferring the
ownership of the asset to the lessee.
Islamic banks are using Ijarah
Muntahia-bi-tamleek as an alternative to a hire purchase and finance lease.
It is an arrangement in which leasing is the real and the major contract that
is subject to all rules of an ordinary operating ijarah contract where
the standard Shari´ah principles of lease, its terms and essential
prerequisites of the contract have to be observed. The transfer of the asset
ownership to the lessee at the end of the lease term is kept separate. It does
not comprise two contracts in one bargain; rather, the real bargain is only one
whereby the lessor leases the asset and fixes the rentals in such a way that
during the lease period the repayment of the cost of the asset and the rental
for leasing the asset are received.
Both parties agree on this nature of the
transaction; and the other part of the deal is only a unilateral promise not
binding on the promissee and as such it is not a transaction until actually
entered into by the parties. Further, this arrangement is fair and based on
justice for both the parties in that the lessee, who has paid the cost along
with the rentals, is able to get ownership title of the asset at the end of the
lease period, while the lessor recovers cost of the leased asset and also the
profit in the form of rentals. However, the lessee is under an obligation to
buy the asset at the end of the lease term.
As owner of the asset, the bank should take out takaful
cover to insure the leased assets. Islamic banks normally include the takaful
expenses in acquisition cost of the asset for determining the rental. Shari´ah
scholars allow this on the ground that rentals in leases are subject to
mutual consent of the two parties and if the lessee agrees to the amount of
rental, the contract would be acceptable from a Shari´ah perspective. As
regards the insurable interest, it rightly belongs to the bank as lessor.
However, the AAOIFI recommends that in case the
transfer of ownership becomes impossible without any cause attributable to the
lessee (the client), the lessee must be protected from the loss by the lessor
paying to the lessee (client) the difference between the rent received as per
the lease agreement and the market rentals of such assets.
If the asset is destroyed, and there is proof for
lack of observance of the conditions of the takaful policy that bars the
bank as lessor from recovery of an insurance claim from the takaful company,
the lessee client is held liable. In the absence of any fault or negligence on
the part of the lessee client, the bank bears all responsibility for damage to
or loss of the leased asset. If the claim paid by the takaful company is
less than the loss incurred by Islamic bank, the uncovered loss cannot be
charged to the lessee and the bank would bear the loss.
In this way, Islamic banks and financial
institution have tried to transform the conventional lease structure to make it
Shari´ah compliant. The arrangement, broadly speaking, comprises two
contracts entered into at different times: One contract is an ordinary lease
contract, where the Shari´ah principles of defining the asset to be
leased, its terms and essential prerequisites of contracts are observed. The
lessee pays, in addition to the rental, a sum which goes towards buying the
The other subsequent contract is a contract for
gift or sale of the leased asset at the end of the lease period and is
independent of the earlier lease contract. Although the rentals to be stipulated
in the lease agreements have to be clearly known and fixed, but the actual and
net rental income of the banks might not be fixed and predetermined. The Shari´ah
principle is that risk cannot be separated from ownership; hence, as the
leased asset remains in bank’s ownership, the bank must remain liable for the
asset. Furthermore, the lease and sale transactions are contracts of two
different nature; they must be kept separate and independent of each other to
avoid the prohibition of two inter-dependent / conditional contracts that also
has the connotation of a sale and buy back arrangement. If the above two
aspects are taken care of, the Islamic banks can adopt any procedure for
leasing the assets, mitigating the risks and transferring ownership to the lessee
through any of the approved methods.